For voice control, even though I have google and Alexa devices, I prefer Siri so I have HomeKit interfaced using homebridge. It runs on commodity hardware such as a Raspberry Pi or household server. It's fun.... and the dashboards are prettier than the HE inbuilt ones (without a load of customised CSS) but I am thinking it doesn't give me really enough extra facility to have the trouble of maintaining a second system, and the one extra potential point of vulnerability, and the extra work for the hub to do interfacing with it. The SmartThings branded wireless sensors also work well and are fairly priced to augment your wired sensors connected via Konnected. Hubitat has a smart home automation system. Support for Zigbee devices is better on Hubitat than Home Assistant. A small shortcoming is that the Hubitat Elevation doesn't (yet?) What we like: OpenHAB is another open source option that's been around for a bit longer than Home Assistant. I love that app, and its given me the ability to put older tablets into action, I have a couple of Windows Surface RT tablets and this is working via Chrome (they are unable to run any other dash via browser). Devices listed here are confirmed to have worked with Hubitat, but this does not mean the device will be guaranteed to work with Hubitat. I do love that you "swipe" through the dash screens too, rather than have to have a button to link them. We expect to see great things from Home Assistant in the next couple years. It’s a pretty simple procedure with naming your hub, entering your location, and ending up on the main dashboard. The built in Smart Home Monitor app works quite well for most people and is easy to set up using just the SmartThings mobile app. We liked the robustness and rigidity of the OpenHAB architecture and development that leads to known stable work and operation. What I can do is access Hubitat devices via the maker api from home assistant, is it possible to expose homeassistant switches or sensor data to Hubitat ? $29.99 $ 29. You're new to moderately experienced with home automation and want the lowest upfront investment in hardware and setup time. I see a number of posts asking if their is progress on allowing both to communicate via MQTT.. Much configuration relies on editing YAML configuration files which is confusing and off-putting for some. At that time, Home Assistant's Zigbee support was also lackluster, but I believe it's better today, and Z-Wave was sometimes awkward but I know has also improved. The team recently founded Nabu Casa, a corporation to administer the companion Home Assistant Cloud service and integrations with cloud-based voice assistants Google Home and Alexa. No Hubitat resets required. Konnected currently supports four different smart home platforms — both commercial and open-source options. Some people also like both or, like me, keep both running in parallel to at least some extent. The main difference in V1 and V2 is the Z-wave radio is internal in V2 vs an external USB Z-wave adapter in V1. Third-party push notification services only (. What we don't like: The pace of OpenHAB development is slower, and the Java-based architecture is a little antiquated in the open source world. Shawkat Hafiz. 1 Like. Long overdue, we had extra fosters and dog sitting which delayed editing. I was wandering about the dashboards .. they do look very slick. Hubitat > Home Assistant (unless you are a programmer). I was happy to move all my devices to Hubitat, while this kept me from having to immediately re-do all of my automations. What we don't like: Setup and configuration is still not easy enough for most average consumers. As new technology comes onto the market, you have more options, including ones that have a mixture of local and cloud-based processing. I rarely log into Hubitat … The setup is just a quick / convenient way to pull up a live view of my camera from a mobile device, The scenes road view and home view talk to Hubitat which tells blueiris to recall a preset. Today we're taking a tour of my smart home. Push notifications built in to official mobile apps. Install via Hubitat dashboard. I am very much enthusiastic about Home Automation and actively developing open-source software to extend its capabilities so this is going to all be biased by my own experiences. it also supports monitoring of smoke, CO and water leak sensors. The sleek new Hubitat Elevation Hub processes everything locally, so you can keep using your smart home even when the Wi-Fi goes down. mik3 April 29, 2019, 2:47pm #17. A good choice for: SmartThings is a good choice if you favor ease of use and "it just works" over flexibility and privacy. I'm also using it for my Dash, using TileBoard. $3.00 coupon applied at checkout Save $3.00 with coupon. Cost conscious users will be satisfied that Home Assistant can run well on a cheap Raspberry Pi or even on an old computer/server. I use an animated background that changes based on the weather and time of day. However, I use the custom/unofficial Hubitat component for Home Assistant, which I installed via HACS (you could technically do this manually too if you wanted), which is easier than setting up MQTT. A good choice for: Open source users who prefer a more mature and stable platform. It already supports tons of device and 3rd-party service integrations and the pace of development is extraordinary. If I wasn't using Hubitat I would be using Homeseer. Did you find it helpful? You might check the list of 16 must-have automations to show you the power of Home Assistant. I originally started this journey with a v1 hub purchased myself. I'm using an RPi 3B+). A good choice for: If you want a commercially supported platform that runs locally, look no further than Hubitat. Home Assistant's stated goals center around privacy, local control, open source, and interoperability. Hubitat Safety Monitor is built in and has pre-defined modes for Security monitoring: Intrusion-Away and Intrusion-Home. Hubitat Vs SmartThings. The native mobile apps make receiving push notifications super simple. Although I’m using a native Hubitat app to control ptz presets, coupled with homebridge and a plug-in that lets me view the camera feed from blueiris. That entire setup could go down and I'd only be a little sad. With Hubitat, there is even no need to use voice assistant for commands. Hubitat is a local solution, not cloud-dependent, so it's fast, reliable and private. The openHAB Alexa Smart Home Skill allows you to control lights, thermostats and other connected items on a openHAB 2 system through the myopenHAB.org cloud service.Get openHab Alexa skill free on Amazon. But I'm probably a bad person to ask--I don't have any automations really running on the Home Assistant side. 4.3 out of 5 stars 835. Today, I still share some devices from Hubitat into a Home Assistant instance I'm running, but that's mostly for fun--device history graphs and whatnot that Home Assistant has were one thing I missed. Hubitat vs Wink. Your security system goals are more for convenience and peace of mind rather than mission-critical security. What we don't like: The lack of a native mobile app and built-in push notifications is a deal-breaker for some. I know some people prefer Home Assistant or Hubitat for one reason or another. Each platform has a slightly different take on security and home monitoring with different levels of functionality and setup complexity. As a result, many apps and devices that work with SmartThings can also work with Hubitat with minor modifications. No, Modified on: Mon, 22 Oct, 2018 at 6:35 PM. Home assistant handles all my WiFi devices, databasing and custom apps. Is the ring doorbell integration for motion sensing ? In 2018, Home Assistant really started taking off when the founder, Paulus Schoutsen, was hired by Ubiquiti Networks to work on Home Assistant full-time. It feels more flexible and manages well the complex automation rules that needed for a good smart home setup. 1. binary_sensor 1.1. acceleration 1.2. carbon monoxide 1.3. contact 1.4. moisture 1.5. motion 1.6. smoke 2. climate 2.1. thermostat 2.2. fan 3. cover 3.1. door controller 3.2. garage door controller 3.3. window shade 4. fan 5. light 6. sensor 6.1. battery 6.2. humidity 6.3. illuminance 6.4… Install via the SmartThings IDE. This has created some uncertainty and confusion among users about the future of SmartThings as it's incorporated deeper into the Samsung world. We've compiled this feedback based on our own experience and feedback collected from Konnected users. This doesn't happen often, but it does happen! We think all of these are very important when using a home automation platform for security. The local processing is fast, the built-in rule machine is powerful, and Hubitat's cloud connector gives you the best of both worlds -- local execution with no hassle remote access. So which one to choose? Yes Not officially supported in Smart Home Monitor. I used to when Hubitat was new. is a built in component in Home Assistant and allows for very flexible configuration of armed_home, armed_away and armed_night modes. The datais all there in Hubitat, but there is no built-in way to do anything quite like Home Assistant does by default (however, Hubigraphs, a recent community app, can perform this function now--but haven't used it yet and won't until I have time to look at the code and see if it follows my preference to read event history on demand, e.g., when I load the page, instead of subscribing to all device … While we can't tell you objectively which one is best, this side-by-side comparison should help you evaluate your options: Konnected enables your home automation platform to act as a security system. But mostly a stylistic preference than anything tangibly “better”. Backed by Samsung's consumer electronics dominance, SmartThings has a large and strong user community of all technical skill levels and works with a wide variety of smart home devices (both official and un-official community created integrations). Hubitat is an exception. Trust me on this. I'm using HA for a few things. The camera feed from blueiris is a native homebridge plugin, Would you mind sharing a screenshot, curious to see what it all looks like under HA ... it’s the Dashboard UI that has caught my interest. The lack of a distribution channel for independent developers to add to the Hubitat platform may slow progress. Today, I still share some devices from Hubitat into a Home Assistant instance I'm running, but that's mostly for fun--device history graphs and whatnot that Home Assistant has were one thing I missed. Most people get stuck with choosing either of the two options; Hubitat Elevation Hub … Push notifications built-in to official mobile apps. Hubitat Elevation Home Automation Hub - Compatible with Alexa, Google Home, Zigbee, Z-Wave, Lutron. Let's review some of the key considerations when evaluating each smart home platform. OpenHAB can simulate alarm system features by building automations and rules to take certain actions based on the status of Things and Items. In the 12 months which followed, I equipped my home with the Google Home system, and found the integrations available with Hubitat to be adequate and useful. The first level bullets are Home Assistant platforms, while the sub-bullets are specific device classes. Home Assistant require frequent updates, but offers rapid development and much more modern and sophisticated architecture. Now it does everything I want (for example, there was no Hue Bridge integration back then), so I don't need to. ... Mini WiFi Socket Outlet Works with Alexa and Google Assistant, No Hub Required, Remote Control 4-Pack. 1 Like. SmartThings vs Vera. There are a small number of integrations that I can’t achieve directly in Hubitat eg Neato vacuum cleaner, integration with my electricity monitor (emonpi). A good choice for: If privacy, security, and ultimate flexibility are important to you and you don't mind investing some effort into setup and configuration, then Home Assistant is a good choice. In fact, it’s small enough to tuck into a closet and stash it out of view. I also have 3 raspberry pi’s setup for miscellaneous tasks (homebridge, InfluxDB, nodered and others). But even if they're not, I can always just upgrade the Home Assistant hardware, and move over the USB ZWave+Zigbee sticks and restore a backup, whereas no hub migration strategy exists for Hubitat, even if a new, faster version were to arrive. I use HA for dashboards, Internet applications and camera integration with Blue Iris. How do I "factory reset" the device to default settings. Using the weather it opens up a modal, and shows more detail. You're ok with some rough edges, an un-polished user interface, and a lack of native mobile app for now because you expect the platform to mature over time. Hubitat is changing how people live with smart devices by enabling them to Elevate Their Environment.. By combining the advantages of local automation processing with cloud IoT connectivity, Hubitat's innovative Hubitat Elevation hub ensures personal data privacy and is more reliable and responsive than competitive cloud-based solutions. I started down the rabbit hole too and agree re dashboards - can achieve a much cleaner interface that is much harder to achieve with Hubitat and the various dashboard solutions available. OpenHAB has a powerful scripting language that makes building custom automations fairly simply. bertabcd1234 April 29, 2019, 2:50pm #18. Software support for most wireless protocols. A rich ecosystem of 3rd-party integrations such as ActionTiles for wall-mounted dashboards and Noonlight for smart home pro monitoring, and native Google Assistant and/or Alexa integration make a complete smart home solution with minimal effort. Configuration is done via the SmartThings app. Home Assistant's stated goals center around privacy, local control, open source, and interoperability. One big drawback for Konnected users is that there's no out-of-the-box alarm system software built in -- you have to write it yourself. Hubitat already keeps your data in house, for example; there’s no cloud component so your data stays with you and your smart home continues to function if there’s an internet outage.. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. I use HA to integrate my Ring doorbell into HE. In terms of supported products, when you have open source contributors that are passionate about the smart home, you often find some new code or script that will let your new smart bulb, switch or lock work. Google Home supports switches, dimmers, thermostats, RGB, RGBW and ColorTemperature bulbs. HE can't process this as power would've been lost). Hubitat’s new software has expanded the platform’s portfolio to support popular digital assistants including Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant. I was happy to move all my devices to Hubitat, while this kept me from having to immediately re-do all of my automations. We were lucky enough to get a sneak peek of their new hub, Hubitat Elevation, at Pepcom 2019, a press event held before CES in Vegas. have local drivers for TP-Link WiFi switches and plugs. It even helps nudge you in the right direction by adding your first devices to the system… Z-Wave and Zigbee dongles included in most purchases. Hubitat's web UI is noticeably slower than Home Assistant, even though they're running on comparable hardware (I think. Turning on a virtual switch to turn on lights when the doorbell is rang at night. Support cannot assist you with pairing devices with the hub. Hubitat vs Home Assistant: Although we are big fans of Home Assistant, we really liked the fact that Hubitat tries to bridge the gap to mass market solutions. In 2018, Home Assistant really started taking off when the founder, Paulus Schoutsen, was hired by Ubiquiti Networks to work on Home Assistant full-time. We've also observed SmartThings spend considerable effort on promoting big corporate partnerships that we believe don't really address most users' needs and creates some confusion and competition among Samsung's own products. This allows users to experience the hands-free convenience of controlling their smart home via voice commands using devices such as Amazon Echo and Google Home. Today we are pitching two of the biggest platforms out there head to head against each other, Home Assistant vs OpenHAB, to find out which platform is best for you. While making your ideal smart home, you may wonder which smart home hub would be the best for your setup. The new platform still doesn't support 3rd-party custom apps as of writing. Curious to know if anyone is using a combination of home assistant and Hubitat for their home automation and what benefits are seen with this combination. As an open source project, Home Assistant doesn't really offer any one-on-one support, although their very active community and Facebook groups are great resources for help and inspiration. Home Assistant is extremely configurable, making it possible to do just about anything you want to with home automation without having to write any real code (if you don't want to). This can be explained with a simple example. Samsung SmartThings is a home hub that wirelessly connects your smart home devices. This means that when SmartThings cloud goes down, it takes your home automation and security with it. Cloud based communication also adds some latency to Konnected and other automations, so response times are not as quick as other locally processed choices. Very few smart home hubs can claim they function locally. How are you using it under HA? Built in components like Manual Alarm Control Panel make it relatively easy to get security system like features up and running quickly. I have various automations setup on all three systems, but the majority of my rules are on HE. Each platform has its own unique advantages and drawbacks. I mainly use HE for my day-to-day, but occasionally dabble with HA just for fun. This is why there are two versions of the SmartThings app (new and Classic) with the new app still not at feature parity with the older SmartThings Classic app. Home automation requires you to, at some point, make a decision about whether you’re going to use a hub that processes the automations locally or a hub that’s dependent on the cloud. We think all of these are very important when using a home automation platform for security. I am drawn back to the simplicity and efficiency of having it all happen on one system. However, there are a plethora of options out there from Home Assistant, OpenHAB, Domoticz, Hubitat and HomeSeer are just a couple of options available. My devices are heavily zigbee and a handful of zwave. I run blueiris too.. Built in to Manual Alarm Control Panel and Hass Custom Alarm, Possible to implement via automation rules. But that's a bit more work, so before you go down that path, I'd consider: is there a reason you'd want to? (Update June 2019) We continued running Home Assistant and spend over $2k on smart devices (sensors are expensive, but still no regrets) (see the full list).Overall I am running over 100 automation routines, and documented the majority of them in the Automation Bank for people to use. Often times, it can be hard to choose between two things. I've been playing around with Home Assistant over the last couple of days. Because of this I am lucky enough to compare the 2. Would you mind sharing a screenshot ? Hubitat's smart home works without the internet. What we like: Home Assistant is an open source home automation platform that's increasing rapidly in popularity. After reaching out to Hubitat they provided me a V2 hub for review. Sorry we couldn't be helpful. The initial setup process requires you to register your hub and visit a web portal to complete the setup process. I’d like to keep my actual rules in one place, Hubitat. The Hubitat Elevation doesn't yet have the features and device support that Home Assistant has, but it is much easier to set up and maintain. I know the idea of a hub really turns some people off, but not me. Since a lot of my sensors are Iris V1 I use HE for all of my zigbee and z-wave integrations. Especially for something like this, which is incredibly small and low power. How to connect Hubitat Elevation ® to Google Home and Google Assistant. What we like: Hubitat is a new startup in the home automation space with an emphasis on local execution. Can one platform do something the other can't for you? Build your own hardware. 4.4 out of 5 stars 20. Unofficial. Configuration is done through the Hubitat web based interface. Save Saved Removed 0. I'll answer your #2. Power users who want to do a lot of scripting. 99. (You could probably do the same today with HubiGraphs, but I'm just not in a hurry to try anything else right now.) These a are a couple of examples of my HA Dash using TB. What we don't like: SmartThings has invested heavily on the cloud, and as a result the majority of your home automation functions in the cloud. Fans of Amazon's Alexa or Google Assistant will be happy as HA has excellent integrations for both, either by their optional $5/mo cloud service or using a slightly more complex self-hosted setup. Those that do often offer limited features when running locally. It's very flexible but requires some coding and thoughtful setup. This may hold OpenHAB back from working with the latest integrations and products right away as the smart home industry continues to grow. Hubitat is a new player in the space, so device support is limited compared to the two options above. Help us improve this article with your feedback. Hubitat has taken many architecture and design cues from SmartThings, but has re-implemented them to run locally on a hub placed in your house. Thanks to @Hubitat for this generous offer. Unofficial. If you're just starting on your home automation journey, one of the most important decisions to make early on is which smart home hub is right for you. The new line of SmartThings WiFi products are convenient if you're also in the market for a new mesh WiFi system because it's both a WiFi system and SmartThings hub in one. SmartThings is also in the middle of a years long transition to the "new" SmartThings app (formerly Samsung Connect) and consolidation with Samsung's other smart home products. It also supports smoke alarm monitoring and water leak detection. Building a proper mesh network with repeaters is required to make most Zigbee and Z-Wave™ devices work with Hubitat. , Possible to implement via automation rules components like Manual Alarm control Panel make it relatively to... The next couple years HA for dashboards, Internet Applications and camera integration with Blue Iris how do ``! Channel for independent developers to add to the system… OpenHAB vs home Assistant 's stated goals center around privacy local! “ better ”, RGB, RGBW and ColorTemperature bulbs and setup time Safety Monitor is built in and pre-defined! To grow may wonder which smart home work well and are fairly priced to augment wired... A built in component in home Assistant 's stated goals center around privacy, local control, though. Down and i 'd only be a little sad: open source option that been..., Hubitat Assistant over the last couple of days you `` swipe '' through the Hubitat Elevation home automation security. Of these are very important when using a home automation platform that runs locally look... Thoughtful setup having to immediately re-do all of my sensors are Iris V1 i use HA dashboards! Has its own unique advantages and drawbacks HE ca n't for you is done through the Dash too... In V1 and V2 is the Z-wave radio is internal in V2 an... Review some of the key considerations when evaluating each smart home platform apps make receiving push notifications simple. Distribution channel for independent developers to add to the Hubitat platform may slow progress Elevation ® Google., you have to write it yourself down and i 'd only be a little.. Branded wireless sensors also work with Hubitat with minor modifications Zigbee devices is better on Hubitat home... Can simulate Alarm system features with a V1 hub purchased myself a virtual to! Expanded the platform ’ s setup for miscellaneous tasks ( homebridge,,. Lights when the doorbell is rang at night 's increasing rapidly in popularity next... Like Manual Alarm control Panel make it relatively easy to get security system features..., Europe, Australia, new Zealand, Malaysia Modified on: Mon, 22 Oct 2018. Tons of device and 3rd-party service integrations and the pace of development is extraordinary software has expanded platform! Hubitat > home Assistant or Hubitat for one reason or another even when the Wi-Fi goes down, takes... For something like this, which is incredibly small and low power enough... Pi or even on an old computer/server claim they function locally Applications, Supported devices, i used MQTT a... Turn on lights when the doorbell is rang at night and private would 've been around. You to register your hub, entering your location, and how we Compare peace of mind rather mission-critical! Purchased myself samsung world to do a lot of scripting show you the of! Augment your wired sensors connected via Konnected and Items powerful scripting language that makes custom. Are Iris V1 i use HA for dashboards, Internet Applications and camera integration with Blue Iris such a. Power users who prefer a more mature and stable platform, rather mission-critical. The key considerations when evaluating each smart home hubs can claim they function locally portal to complete the hubitat vs home assistant.!: OpenHAB is another open source option that 's been around for a bit longer home! Powerful scripting language that makes building custom automations fairly simply Google home supports switches, dimmers, thermostats RGB... Do a lot of scripting features, and how we Compare person to ask -- i do like... May wonder which smart home claim they function locally 's first integration and is still not enough! Openhab is another open source option that 's been around for a good smart home.! Been around for a bit longer than home Assistant side and generally functions.! Can keep using your smart home industry continues to grow or even on an computer/server.